🏆 FIRST TAKE: Stephen A. Smith Says Mahomes CANNOT Be the GOAT Until Chiefs Win Without Andy Reid! 😱🔥

The Patrick Mahomes GOAT debate just got a massive twist, thanks to Stephen A. Smith. In a fiery discussion on First Take, Stephen A. made it clear—Mahomes cannot be considered the greatest of all time unless he wins a Super Bowl without Andy Reid.

🔴 Is he right? Does Mahomes need to prove he can win on his own?
🔴 Is Andy Reid the REAL reason for the Chiefs’ success?
🔴 What did Shannon Sharpe say in response?

📌 This debate is shaking up the NFL world—let’s break it all down!

🔥 THE CASE AGAINST MAHOMES AS THE GOAT

On First Take, Stephen A. didn’t hold back when discussing Mahomes’ legacy:

💬 “Mahomes is phenomenal, no doubt about that. But the greatest of all time? Not yet.”

💬 “Every championship he’s won has been with Andy Reid—one of the greatest coaches in NFL history.”

💬 “If we’re talking GOAT status, we have to ask: Could Mahomes do this WITHOUT Andy Reid? We don’t know!”

😱 WAIT… IS HE SAYING MAHOMES IS OVERRATED?!

Not exactly. Stephen A. respects Mahomes’ talent but believes true GOATs win under ANY circumstances.

He compared Mahomes to Tom Brady, who won Super Bowls with Bill Belichick AND proved himself by winning with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers without Belichick.

🚨 Mahomes hasn’t done that yet.

💥 SHANNON SHARPE FIRES BACK!

Shannon Sharpe wasn’t having it. He immediately jumped in to defend Mahomes, saying:

💬 “So now we’re penalizing Mahomes for having a great coach? That’s ridiculous!”

💬 “You think Joe Montana wasn’t helped by Bill Walsh? You think Brady didn’t benefit from Belichick?”

💬 “Mahomes is already doing things we’ve NEVER SEEN. He’s in the GOAT conversation, period.”

🔥 AND THE DEBATE GOT EVEN HOTTER! 🔥

🤔 WHO IS REALLY RESPONSIBLE FOR THE CHIEFS’ SUCCESS?

Let’s break it down:

✅ Andy Reid is a coaching genius. Before Mahomes, he took the Eagles to a Super Bowl and made Alex Smith look elite in Kansas City.

✅ Patrick Mahomes is a generational talent. He does things NO OTHER quarterback can do—his arm strength, mobility, and football IQ are unmatched.

But here’s the question:

🚨 Would Mahomes be just as great without Andy Reid?
🚨 Would the Chiefs still be dominant with a different coach?
🚨 Or is it Reid’s system that makes Mahomes look unstoppable?

This is exactly what Stephen A. Smith is questioning.

💣 SO, CAN MAHOMES BE THE GOAT?

Right now, Mahomes’ resume is insane:

🏆 3x Super Bowl appearances
🏆 2x Super Bowl wins
🏆 2x MVPs
🏆 5x AFC Championship Games

🚨 BUT… all of this has been with Andy Reid. 🚨

For Mahomes to be the undisputed GOAT, he may have to prove he can win without him.

📢 WHAT DO YOU THINK?

📲 Does Mahomes NEED to win without Andy Reid to be the GOAT?
📲 Or is he already proving he’s the best we’ve ever seen?
📲 Is Stephen A. Smith right, or is Shannon Sharpe making the better argument?

💬 Drop your thoughts in the comments! Let’s settle this debate! 🏈🔥